Please let us know whether you agree.
Scottish Rugby believes it has a valid case from the governing body since it seeks to make sure their World Cup match that is decisive with Japan goes ahead of the game.
World Rugby will make a decision on Sunday about if the game in Yokohama can proceed as Typhoon Hagibis is prepared for by the host country.
It has cancelled two Saturday games and declared them an attraction, but the exit of Scotland could be meant by a duplicate.
But SRU chief executive Mark Dodson stateslegal ruling unravels its case.
The side of gregor Townsend lie behind Ireland and Japan in Pool A and must beat the hosts – and also take more points – to progress to the quarter-final point unless the Irish lose to Samoa.
World Rugby rules state thatwhere a pool game cannot be commenced on the day in which it is scheduled, it will be delayed to the next day and will be considered as cancelled. In cases like this, the result will probably be allocated two points each and no score enrolled.
For World Rugby to simply say that the game has to be cancelled against the entire sporting ethics of the championship, Dodson told the Today programme on BBC Radio 4.
World Rugby have led us back into the engagement agreement and that it is clearly stated there. We have had a legal opinion and then weve taken a major sports QC opinion in London that battles that and unravels the World Rugby case.
World Rugby expects the match will proceed and that the worst of the typhoon will have passed by Sunday, however, its refusal to look at moving the match to venue or another time angers Dodson.
We have been preparing for this tournament today for the previous four decades, our guys are around 100 days at camp, weve played three games already and the fourth game in this particular case is critical, he added.
My view is that we are not going to allow Scotland function as collateral damage for a decision that was taken in haste.
Dodson contended that rugby supporters around the globeare completely astounded at this rigidity out of World Rugby and believes the match ought to be played Monday if it cant proceed on Sunday.
The common sense approach to this is to play the sport 24 hours afterwards on perfect security where we can make sure that the pool phases are completed, along with the athletic integrity of the championship remains intact, he added.
There was someone out there that did who can do it and take action again
Trash conversation, haka struggles, new stars burning bright and nation-uniting triumphs – how much do you recall of these mythical Rugby World Cup moments?
Get latest scores and headlines delivered straight to your phoneto our newsletter and also find out where to locate us on internet.
The way to enter rugby union – through the age groups up to the 15-player game or try rugby sevens, which made its Olympic debut in 2016.
Enjoy the discussion, analysis and interviews with all BBC 5 live and World Service and our rugby union commentary listings.
Read more here: http://carolinemorin.fr/wordpress/?p=1555